| by
William R. Stimson
How strange China should be undertaking such a huge military
buildup, and conducting so much of it behind the scenes, in a
clandestine fashion. One wonders who it perceives to be its enemy
when the whole world benefits from its new prosperity and success,
welcomes it with open arms, scrambles to invest in its big future
and wants "in" on its economic miracle. Schoolchildren
the world over are learning Mandarin. Everybody knows China is
the future. "Nobody is going to attack China," stammers
the U.S. Secretary of Defense Rumsfield, apparently at a loss
to understand why it is hurrying so to arm itself.
Across the water from China sits peaceful little Taiwan, with
its bustling democracy and free market economy - the major engine
of
China's growth. How many other developing countries wish they
had a Taiwan off their shore. It would be hard to calculate the
extent to which Taiwan benefits China day in and day out. How
strange then that following Taiwan's disastrous earthquake a few
years back, China prevented emergency relief from being flown
in to Taiwan over Chinese territory. At the height of the SARS
episode, China blocked Taiwan's entry into the World Health Organization.
A pandemic bird flu disaster looms in the region. China continues
to block Taiwan's entry. Again and again, Taiwan has said it wants
peaceful relations with China. Yet China now has hundreds of missiles
aimed at Taiwan. Can anyone doubt that the armada of modern troop
ships, submarines and airplanes that China is currently amassing
at such a breakneck pace is for use against Taiwan?
Stranger stories every day come out of China, one after another.
Recently a Chinese journalist who wrote against corruption in
his
newspaper and won an award for his probity was beaten and had
some fingers hacked off. That writer will never type again. Another
Chinese journalist received a long prison sentence, just for sending
an e-mail. The Chinese doctor who blew the whistle on SARS was
"disappeared" along with his wife for speaking out truthfully
about the Tienaman Square massacre. The internet in China is tightly
controlled; yet, no sooner did Japan announce it would come to
Taiwan's assistance in the event of a Chinese attack, than an
anti-Japanese movement easily organized itself on China's controlled
internet, sent out all the e-mails it wanted and staged riots
across China. Chinese police stood idly by as demonstrators smashed
Japanese property. What was it all about? The excuse about Japan's
offenses during the war would be more believable if China hadn't
itself committed those same offenses in Tibet. The excuse about
the Japanese textbooks would be believable if China's textbooks
didn't still omit the truth about Tibet and about Tienaman Square.
The excuse about the Japanese leader paying homage to an offensive
shrine would be believable if Mao's picture wasn't still prominently
displayed as an object of reverence in Beijing. Japan's commitment
to defend Taiwan was the reason behind China's temper tantrum.
China has not only probed Japanese waters with its submarines
but is insanely probing weaknesses in the defense system of the
United States, Taiwan's chief protector. "We are smarter
than you!" Chinese sites brag to the Americans - uncensored
on China's highly censored internet. On 9/11, Chinese sites expressed
glee over pictures of the burning towers in New York City - likewise
uncensored. Earlier this year, sites all around China likened
the visiting American Secretary of State to a "monkey"
because of her African ancestry and called her "ugly"
and "stupid" - also uncensored. Towards any country
standing in the way of its designs on Taiwan, China behaves less
like a modern civilized nation, than like a primitive and crude
barbarian.
If we look at China's history, we can see why. Over the last
5,000 years, China has again and again been conquered and ruled
by barbarians - barbarians from the outside, and "barbarians"
from the inside. Never once has it been conquered and ruled by
its own people, like newly democratic Taiwan. This is the real
threat Taiwan poses to China - it is free. And so long as it sits
there free - prospering, and making China prosper; thriving, and
making China thrive; bristling with enterprise, and making China
bristle with enterprise - democratic Taiwan shows up the lie of
China's barbarian rule and the lie of Chinese history. China wasn't
made weak by foreign invaders. It was invaded by foreigners because
it was made weak by its own corrupt despots. China's weakness
has been its lack of freedom. This is still true today. Where
there is freedom people can speak out and put an end to corruption
and the abuse of power that tear a country apart at its root.
The huge military buildup underway in China today is not to protect
China and the Chinese people from any outside enemy because China
has no outside enemy. Its purpose is to protect China's rulers
from the Chinese people. It is poised to strike Taiwan because
Taiwan is an embodiment of the pre-eminent danger felt by those
rulers - Taiwan is a shining example of Chinese people successfully
governing themselves, making their own decisions, being free -
and thriving as a result, and making everyone thrive all around
them. The very existence of Taiwan's huge success cries out to
China's tyrants something they are terrified the rest of China
might hear - "The people can rule themselves."
Because of the reason for which it is being carried out, the
effect of China's military build-up will not be to make China
strong, but to
perpetuate its historic weakness. The same is true for China's
ongoing inquisition against those of its own people honest and
courageous enough to openly speak the truth. And the same is true
for China's censorship of the internet, blocking of websites,
and suppression of Hong Kong's pro-democracy movement. All these
policies perpetuate China's historic weakness. The way to strength
is to confront and expose weakness, and then eliminate it. For
China to be great, this is the strategy it needs to take. It is
time for those who love China, in its military and in its government,
to stop covering up China's weakness and inner corruption and
to make China strong instead - by making it free. The only ones
who might be hurt by this are those who are doing the damage -
China's real enemies. The corrupt, not the honest, need to be
rooted out and put in jail.
China can't keep wasting precious resources fighting the truth.
It needs to get on with the business of the day - which is to
throw off
the barbarian model, and allow itself, for the first time in its
long history, to be conquered finally by its own people. Democracy
and
freedom alone can release Chinas vast and unfathomable potential.
It happened in Taiwan. It can happen in China the same way.
Instead of bullying Taiwan or trying to make a grab for it, China
should be doing everything in its power to assist its successful
little
brother and to follow his proud example. A good first step would
be for China to let the people of Taiwan themselves decide their
future. Nobody in the whole world is against Taiwan being a part
of China, if the Taiwanese people choose that. If China could
only bring itself to give the people of Taiwan this choice, then
no matter which way the Taiwanese people decide to go, China will
come away the big winner - because it will have discovered, finally
after 5,000 years, that its strength lies not in tyranny but in
freedom.
* * *
William R. Stimson is a writer who lives in Taiwan. More of his
writing can be found at www.billstimson.com
|